Destinations / Compare
York vs Edinburgh
York and Edinburgh both offer medieval streets, a famous skyline and more history than you can see in one weekend. But they feel different. York is small, flat and walled, so you can cross the centre in 20 minutes and spend the rest of the day in museums, tearooms and old pubs. Edinburgh is a capital city built over hills and volcanic rock, with a castle, a big festival calendar and a livelier evening scene. Choose by the pace you want, not just by which one looks better in photos.
Side by side
- Daily budget estimate (solo, mid-range): York US$130 to $230, including accommodation; Edinburgh US$150 to $280, including accommodation and the 5% visitor levy
- Best seasons: York April to June and September to October; Christmas markets in late November and December; Edinburgh May to September; August festivals bring peak prices
- Ideal first visit: York 2 to 3 days; Edinburgh 3 to 5 days
- Getting around: York Walk the centre; buses and park and ride for the outskirts; Edinburgh Lothian buses and trams; tap contactless for a daily cap
- Food: York Sunday roasts, Yorkshire puddings, tearooms and market stalls; Edinburgh Haggis, Scottish seafood, Leith restaurants and whisky bars
- Shopping: York The Shambles, Fossgate and independent shops; Edinburgh Victoria Street, Stockbridge and St James Quarter
- Nightlife: York Historic pubs, Micklegate bars and ghost walks; Edinburgh Grassmarket, Cowgate clubs and folk music sessions
- First-time base: York Inside the walls near the Minster, or Bootham; Edinburgh Old Town, New Town or Stockbridge
- Navigation: York Small and flat; Google Maps is plenty; Edinburgh Hills, steps and closes; allow extra time between sights
- Day trips: York Whitby, Castle Howard or Harrogate; Edinburgh North Berwick, Stirling or a Highlands tour
Verdict
Choose York for a relaxed, walkable break with Roman and Viking history, cosy pubs and easy day trips into Yorkshire. Choose Edinburgh for a bigger city with dramatic views, hill walks, whisky bars and festivals. Allow 2 to 3 days for York or 3 to 5 for Edinburgh. With about a week, you can visit both comfortably, as direct trains link them in roughly two and a half hours.
York is best for
- Compact, flat sightseeing on foot
- Roman, Viking and medieval history
- Traditional pubs and afternoon tea
- Solo travellers who want a calm short break
Edinburgh is best for
- Castle views and hill walks in the city
- Festivals, live music and late nights
- Whisky bars and Scottish seafood
- A capital city with plenty of day trips
Frequently asked questions
Is York or Edinburgh cheaper to visit?
York usually costs a little less for a comparable hotel, and many of its best sights, such as the city walls and the National Railway Museum, are free. Edinburgh now adds a 5% visitor levy to the first five nights of paid accommodation, and prices jump during the August festivals. The daily ranges here are planning estimates, not live quotes; compare accommodation for your actual dates before deciding.
York or Edinburgh for a first solo trip?
Both are easy to manage alone with normal precautions. York is ideal if you want a gentle pace, since you can walk everywhere and pubs and tearooms feel relaxed for solo diners. Edinburgh has more going on after dark, plenty of hostels and walking tours, and an easy bus network. Choose York for a calm break or Edinburgh for a busier city trip.
Which has better food, York or Edinburgh?
Edinburgh has the wider choice, from Leith seafood restaurants to whisky bars and modern Scottish cooking. York does traditional food well, with proper Sunday roasts, afternoon tea and a good market food hall. Book ahead for popular places in both cities, especially at weekends.
Can I visit York and Edinburgh on the same trip?
Yes. Direct LNER and CrossCountry trains run between the two, usually taking around 2 hours 15 minutes to 2 hours 40 minutes. Booking in advance gets cheaper fares. Around 5 to 7 days gives you a useful stay in each city. If you need a UK ETA to enter the country, one covers both England and Scotland.
When is the best time to visit York and Edinburgh?
Late spring and early autumn are comfortable in both, with long days and fewer crowds than summer. Edinburgh is busiest and most expensive in August, and again over Hogmanay. York gets crowded around its Christmas markets. Winter days are short and often wet in both, and Edinburgh is usually windier and a little colder.
People also compare
- Edinburgh vs Dublin
- Edinburgh vs Glasgow
- London vs Edinburgh
- Edinburgh vs Belfast
- Inverness vs Edinburgh
- Edinburgh vs Isle of Skye
Plan your trip
Plan a York trip · York guide · York in 3 days
Plan a Edinburgh trip · Edinburgh guide · Edinburgh in 3 days
Joy Plus home | Destinations | Itineraries | Activities | Flights | Budget planner | Calendar | Map | Blog | Lifetime access