Destinations / Compare

Chicago vs New York

Chicago and New York both give you famous skylines, serious museums and neighbourhoods with their own food and personality. The pace is different, though. New York is relentless, with more to see than any one trip can hold, and hotel prices to match. Chicago is roomier and easier on the wallet, with architecture, a long lakefront and live blues and comedy. Choose by how much energy and budget you have, not just by the bigger name.

Side by side

  • Daily budget estimate (solo, mid-range): Chicago US$150 to $260, including accommodation; New York US$230 to $420, including accommodation
  • Best seasons: Chicago Late May to September; winters are bitterly cold; New York April to June and September to early December
  • Ideal first visit: Chicago 3 to 5 days; New York 5 to 7 days
  • Getting around: Chicago The 'L' trains and buses; a Ventra card or app costs less than tapping a bank card; New York 24-hour subway and buses; tap to pay with OMNY at a flat $3 fare
  • Food: Chicago Deep-dish pizza, Italian beef, hot dogs and Pilsen taquerias; New York Pizza slices, bagels, dumplings and food halls
  • Shopping: Chicago Magnificent Mile, Wicker Park and Andersonville; New York SoHo, Fifth Avenue and Williamsburg
  • Nightlife: Chicago Blues bars, improv theatres and West Loop restaurants; New York Broadway, jazz clubs, rooftop bars and the East Village
  • First-time base: Chicago The Loop, River North or West Loop; New York Midtown, Lower East Side or Williamsburg
  • Navigation: Chicago Google Maps works well; the city grid is easy to follow; New York Google Maps or Citymapper for subway routes
  • Day trips: Chicago Indiana Dunes, Milwaukee or Oak Park; New York Beacon in the Hudson Valley, Long Island beaches or Philadelphia

Verdict

Choose New York for Broadway, world-class museums, endless neighbourhoods and a city that never really slows down. Choose Chicago for architecture, the lakefront, blues and comedy, and better value on hotels. Allow 3 to 5 days for Chicago or 5 to 7 for New York. With around 10 days, you can fly between them and enjoy both.

Chicago is best for

  • Architecture tours and riverside walks
  • Lakefront beaches and cycling in summer
  • Blues clubs and improv comedy
  • Solo travellers who want a big city on a smaller budget

New York is best for

  • Broadway shows and live performance
  • Major museums and galleries
  • Neighbourhood hopping across five boroughs
  • Food from almost every cuisine, at any hour

Frequently asked questions

Is Chicago or New York cheaper to visit?

Chicago is usually cheaper, mainly because its hotels cost much less than New York's, where average room rates have hit record highs. Food and transport costs are closer between the two. The daily ranges here are rough estimates, not live prices, so check hotels for your actual dates before you decide.

Chicago or New York for a first solo trip?

You can get around either on your own, as long as you take the usual big-city precautions. New York has more to do alone, with 24-hour trains and plenty of counter seating. Chicago is calmer and easier to find your way around, and many visitors find it a gentler start. Late at night, use busy stations or a taxi.

Which has better food, Chicago or New York?

New York has the bigger range, from cheap slices and bagels to almost any cuisine you can name. Chicago does its own classics really well, including deep-dish pizza, Italian beef and Mexican food in Pilsen. Both have plenty of places with bar seating that suit eating alone.

Can I visit Chicago and New York on the same trip?

Yes. Nonstop flights usually take around 2 to 2.5 hours, with plenty of departures every day. Once you add airport time and transfers, it takes up most of a day. The Amtrak train runs overnight and takes roughly 20 hours. About 8 to 10 days gives you a decent stay in each city.

When is the best time to visit Chicago and New York?

Late spring and early autumn are comfortable in both cities. Chicago is at its best in summer, when the lakefront is busy and there are festivals most weekends, but its winters are harsh. New York's hotels are priciest around December, and January is usually much cheaper if you can put up with the cold.

People also compare

Plan your trip

Plan a Chicago trip · Chicago guide · Chicago in 3 days

Plan a New York trip · New York guide · New York in 3 days


Joy Plus home | Destinations | Itineraries | Activities | Flights | Budget planner | Calendar | Map | Blog | Lifetime access