Destinations / Compare

Philadelphia vs New York

Philadelphia and New York are less than two hours apart by train, but they feel very different. Philadelphia is compact and walkable, with colonial history, murals, and a food scene that's grown well beyond cheesesteaks. You can see a lot of it on foot without spending much. New York is bigger, louder and much more expensive, with world-class museums, Broadway and neighbourhoods across five boroughs. Choose by how much ground you want to cover and how much you're happy to spend on a bed.

Side by side

  • Daily budget estimate (solo, mid-range): Philadelphia US$160 to $280, including accommodation; New York US$280 to $480, including accommodation
  • Best seasons: Philadelphia April to June and September to October; New York April to June and September to early December
  • Ideal first visit: Philadelphia 3 to 4 days; New York 5 to 7 days
  • Getting around: Philadelphia Walkable centre plus SEPTA Metro, buses and trolleys; New York Subway and buses; tap a card or phone with OMNY
  • Food: Philadelphia Reading Terminal Market, cheesesteaks and BYOB bistros; New York Pizza slices, bagels, delis and every cuisine going
  • Shopping: Philadelphia Rittenhouse Square, South Street and Old City boutiques; New York Fifth Avenue, SoHo and Williamsburg vintage shops
  • Nightlife: Philadelphia Fishtown bars, Passyunk and Center City cocktail bars; New York East Village bars, Brooklyn clubs and jazz in the Village
  • First-time base: Philadelphia Center City, Rittenhouse or Old City; New York Midtown, Lower Manhattan or Williamsburg
  • Navigation: Philadelphia Google Maps works well; the centre is a simple grid; New York Google Maps or Citymapper for subway changes
  • Day trips: Philadelphia Valley Forge, Longwood Gardens or New York; New York Hudson Valley, Long Island beaches or Philadelphia

Verdict

Choose Philadelphia for American history, relaxed walking, a strong food scene and much lower hotel prices. Choose New York for major museums, Broadway, nightlife and the sheer variety of neighbourhoods. Allow 3 to 4 days for Philadelphia or 5 to 7 for New York. With around 10 days, you can visit both easily, and the train between them takes about 70 to 90 minutes.

Philadelphia is best for

  • American history and colonial sights
  • Walkable neighbourhoods and street murals
  • Food halls, BYOB restaurants and cheap eats
  • Solo travellers watching their budget

New York is best for

  • World-class museums and galleries
  • Broadway shows and live music
  • Nightlife that runs into the early hours
  • Neighbourhood hopping across five boroughs

Frequently asked questions

Is Philadelphia or New York cheaper to visit?

Philadelphia is usually much cheaper, mainly because hotels cost less. New York's average nightly hotel rate is now well over US$300 and climbs further in autumn and December. Meals and transport are cheaper in Philadelphia too. The daily ranges here are planning estimates, not live quotes, so check accommodation for your dates.

Philadelphia or New York for a first solo trip?

Both work well alone with normal city precautions. Philadelphia is smaller and easier to get to grips with, and most sights are within walking distance. New York has more going on and plenty of counter seating and solo-friendly bars, but it can feel overwhelming at first. Choose Philadelphia for an easy pace or New York for variety.

Which has better food, Philadelphia or New York?

New York has more choice, from pizza slices and bagels to food from almost every country. Philadelphia punches above its size, with Reading Terminal Market, Italian Market stalls and lots of BYOB restaurants that keep dinner costs down. For value, Philadelphia often comes out ahead.

Can I visit Philadelphia and New York on the same trip?

Yes, easily. Amtrak trains take about 70 to 90 minutes between 30th Street Station and Penn Station, and fares are cheaper when booked early. Buses take around 2 hours and are usually cheapest. A slower SEPTA and NJ Transit combination via Trenton costs around US$25 to $30 with no advance booking.

When is the best time to visit Philadelphia and New York?

Spring and autumn are the most comfortable in both cities. Summers are hot and humid, and winters can be cold with occasional snow. New York hotel prices peak in autumn and December, while January is usually the cheapest month if you don't mind the cold.

People also compare

Plan your trip

Plan a Philadelphia trip · Philadelphia guide · Philadelphia in 3 days

Plan a New York trip · New York guide · New York in 3 days


Joy Plus home | Destinations | Itineraries | Activities | Flights | Budget planner | Calendar | Map | Blog | Lifetime access