Destinations / Compare
Montreal vs New York
Montreal and New York are only a short flight apart, but they feel very different. Montreal is relaxed and French-speaking. You spend long evenings on bistro terraces, wander through the Plateau and stop at markets that set the pace of the day. New York is faster and louder, and there's more of it, with world-class museums, Broadway and a different neighbourhood every few subway stops. Choose by how intense you want your trip to be and how much you're happy to spend.
Side by side
- Daily budget estimate (solo, mid-range): Montreal US$120 to $220, including accommodation; New York US$230 to $400, including accommodation
- Best seasons: Montreal Late May to June and September to early October; New York April to June and September to early November
- Ideal first visit: Montreal 3 to 4 days; New York 5 to 7 days
- Getting around: Montreal Métro and buses; the 24-hour pass covers the 747 airport bus; New York Subway and buses; tap a card or phone, US$3 a ride
- Food: Montreal Bagels, smoked meat, poutine and BYOB bistros; New York Pizza slices, delis, bagels and every global cuisine
- Shopping: Montreal Mile End boutiques, Rue Saint-Denis and Atwater Market; New York SoHo, Fifth Avenue and Williamsburg vintage stores
- Nightlife: Montreal Boulevard Saint-Laurent bars and summer festivals; New York Lower East Side bars, Brooklyn venues and Broadway
- First-time base: Montreal Plateau Mont-Royal, Mile End or Old Montreal; New York Midtown, Lower Manhattan or Williamsburg
- Navigation: Montreal Google Maps works well; signs are mostly in French; New York Google Maps or Citymapper; Manhattan's grid helps
- Day trips: Montreal Quebec City, Mont-Tremblant or the Eastern Townships; New York Beacon in the Hudson Valley, Philadelphia or the Rockaways
Verdict
Choose Montreal for European-style streets, a lively food scene and a city that's easier on your budget. Choose New York for big-name museums, theatre, shopping and the energy of a huge city. Allow 3 to 4 days for Montreal or 5 to 7 for New York. With about 10 days, you can see both and take the scenic train between them.
Montreal is best for
- A French-speaking city without crossing an ocean
- Bagels, smoked meat and BYOB bistros
- Summer festivals and terrace culture
- Solo travellers who want a slower, walkable city
New York is best for
- World-class museums and Broadway shows
- Food from almost every cuisine on earth
- Shopping from SoHo to Brooklyn vintage
- Nightlife and live music any night of the week
Frequently asked questions
Is Montreal or New York cheaper to visit?
Montreal is usually much cheaper, mainly because hotels cost far less than in Manhattan. Meals and drinks are also often cheaper, especially if you bring your own wine to BYOB restaurants. Tax and tips are extra in both cities. The daily ranges here are planning estimates, not live quotes, so compare accommodation for your actual dates before deciding.
Montreal or New York for a first solo trip?
Both are manageable alone with normal big-city precautions, and both have good public transport. Montreal is calmer and easy to cover on foot, and English is widely spoken alongside French. New York has more to do on your own, from museums to comedy clubs, but it's more tiring and costs more. Choose Montreal for a gentle start or New York for non-stop activity.
Which has better food, Montreal or New York?
New York has more range, from cheap slices and food halls to famous restaurants in every cuisine. Montreal is smaller but has a strong identity, with wood-fired bagels, smoked meat, Québécois bistros and Jean-Talon Market. Eating alone is easy in both, and bar seating is common in good restaurants.
Can I visit Montreal and New York on the same trip?
Yes. Flights take around 1.5 hours. Amtrak's Adirondack train takes roughly 11 hours along the Hudson River and Lake Champlain, and it's one of the most scenic rides in the eastern US. About 8 to 10 days gives you a useful stay in each city. You'll cross the US-Canada border, so bring your passport and check entry rules for both countries.
When is the best time to visit Montreal and New York?
Late spring and early autumn are comfortable in both. Montreal's summer brings big festivals and busy terraces, but its winter is long and very cold. New York can be hot and humid in July and August. December is popular for holiday lights in New York, so expect higher hotel prices that month.
People also compare
- New York vs London
- Chicago vs New York
- Montreal vs Quebec City
- New York vs Los Angeles
- Boston vs New York
- Montreal vs Toronto
Plan your trip
Plan a Montreal trip · Montreal guide · Montreal in 3 days
Plan a New York trip · New York guide · New York in 3 days
Joy Plus home | Destinations | Itineraries | Activities | Flights | Budget planner | Calendar | Map | Blog | Lifetime access